How do Rules of Order work at Convention ?
Convention includes more than 2000 participants including delegates, alternates, observers and guests.
- There are pro and con mics for each region.
- Regional order is determined by a draw.
- Regional order determines the sequence of speakers at the mics.
- The Chair – The President of the union – will go around the room and recognize each speaker in turn.
- You can’t speak a second time until they have gone around the room.
- You can’t amend a resolution at Convention – you can make a recommendation that is taken back to a committee for review.
- Alternates can speak at the ALT mics and have a voice but no vote.
- Observers and guests do not have a voice or a vote.
The Rules of Order we use at Convention
The rules of order we use at Convention include some modifications to Roberts Rules. These are in Article 13 of the Constitution. Some highlights include:
- A person may speak for only 3 minutes
- Identify yourself by name and local – we also may also choose to share our preferred pronouns.
- Once you have spoken you can’t speak again until all others at the mics have had a chance to speak.
- The Chair can participate in debate provided they give up the Chair until the motion is decided upon.
- A member may challenge the decision of the Chair.
Article 13 of the Constitution:
- Before speaking, unless it be on a point of order, a motion for reconsideration or objection to consideration, or a motion for the Orders of the Day, or a question of privilege, a delegate must be recognized by the Chairperson. On being recognized, a delegate shall immediately identify themself by name, Local and/or location.
- When two or more delegates seek recognition simultaneously, the Chairperson shall decide the order in which they shall be recognized.
- No delegate may speak for more than three minutes on any motion and no delegate may speak twice on the same motion until all other delegates who wish to speak on that motion have had an opportunity to do so.
- No delegate may interrupt another delegate who has the floor except for the points or motions listed in Rule 1, above.
- Any delegate who refuses to take their seat when called upon by the Chairperson to do so may, at the discretion of the Chairperson, be suspended from the remainder of the Convention or any part thereof, and if any delegate persistently engages in unparliamentary behaviour, the Chairperson shall name them and ask the Convention to impose appropriate sanctions.
- The Chairperson may participate in a debate provided they vacate the Chair and does not return until the question has been disposed of.
- Any motion, once the debate has begun, becomes the business of the Convention and may be withdrawn or replaced by the mover only if there is no objection or, if there be any objection, only with the consent of the Convention.
- Where a motion or resolution may be amended, an amendment, and an amendment to the amendment (i.e., a sub-amendment), shall be in order. No further sub-amendment shall be in order until the first has been disposed of.
- Questions shall normally be decided by a show of hands or other acceptable method. Where reasonable doubt may exist, on demand by at least 20 delegates, another show of hands or equivalent shall be called for. Only then, on demand by at least 20 delegates, shall a counted vote be taken. Abuse of this rule shall be considered unparliamentary behaviour, subject to Rule 5. On a motion, supported by a majority of delegates present and voting, a roll-call vote shall be ordered. The motion for a roll-call vote may be moved at any time prior to the question being called.
- A majority or a two-thirds majority in any vote shall be calculated on the basis of delegates present and voting, or casting valid ballots (in the case of written votes).
- The Chairperson may vote on any question. In the case of a tie, they may cast the deciding vote. If they do not break the tie, the motion is lost.
- A delegate may challenge a decision of the Chairperson. A seconder is required and the issue is not debatable except that the challenger and the Chairperson may each, respectively, state briefly the basis for the challenge and the decision. The Chairperson shall then vacate the Chair and a Vice-Chairperson shall put the question: “Shall the decision of the Chairperson be the decision of this assembly?” A majority vote is required to overturn the decision of the Chairperson.
- No delegate who has spoken on a question may move or second referral, the previous question, or any other motion that would have the effect of denying or limiting the right of others to speak on the question.
- A motion to adjourn, table, postpone, or otherwise delay may be repeated after progress.
- A delegate may move “that the previous question be put.” It is not debatable and, if adopted by a two-thirds majority, has the effect of closing debate on only the immediate motion, amendment, or sub-amendment.
- Any committee bringing a resolution or report before the Convention shall move adoption, any recommendation of the committee notwithstanding.
- Resolutions and reports of committees may not be amended on the floor of the Convention but they may be referred back without instruction, which is not debatable, or with instructions, which is debatable.
- A motion to reconsider a question may be made by a delegate who voted with the prevailing side on that question. This motion must be made during the same or immediately succeeding session of the Convention at which the question was decided and must be supported by a majority.
- A notice of motion to reconsider a question may be given by any delegate who voted with the prevailing side and such notice must be given at the same session of the Convention at which the question was decided. The motion to reconsider then stands to be called up at the next session, or within 24 hours. Any delegate may call up the motion, which requires a simple majority vote to be adopted. If not called up within 24 hours, or if final adjournment shall have intervened, the effect of the notice is lost.
- When debate begins on the substance of a resolution or constitutional amendment, the Chairperson shall give the opportunity to speak first to a delegate chosen by and from the organization(s) that originated it. If this interrupts the established speaking order, the previous order shall be resumed after the delegate speaks.
- The Rules of Order and the Order of Business, once adopted, may be changed only by a two-thirds vote.
- Any rule of order and procedure can be temporarily suspended by a two-thirds majority of the delegates registered.
13.12 The quorum at any Convention shall be one half of the delegates registered and entitled to vote.
Resolutions and Constitutional Amendments
Resolutions and constitutional amendments must be submitted in advance of the OPSEU/SEFPO Convention and meet the deadline for acceptance. The Resolutions Committee and Constitution Committee decide which resolutions and constitutional amendments will come to the floor at Convention.
To see which resolutions and constitutional amendments will be debated, please refer to the Convention Materials Sections G and H.
Delegates may put forward an Emergency Resolution for consideration by filling in a form at the back of the room during Convention.
Resolutions are motions or proposals submitted to the Convention, urging a policy or a course of action that will guide the union in the coming months or years. OPSEU/SEFPO’s Policy Manual, sent to all Local Presidents, contains all the current resolutions adopted by past conventions, as well as those passed by the Executive Board. Resolutions require approval by a majority of the voting delegates.
Constitutional Amendments are changes to the actual wording of the Constitution.
Because constitutional amendments change the union’s basic structure or administration, they require approval by 2/3 of the voting delegates.
How to speak for or against a resolution or constitutional amendment at Convention
- Section G containing the resolutions is distributed to the members attending Convention. A printed copy of Section G is distributed to all delegates, alternates, observers and guests upon registration at Convention at the Metro Toronto Convention Centre.
- A member may prepare in advance to speak to a given resolution or constitutional amendment.
- A member rises and goes to the PRO or CON mic with their Region number
- The Chair recognizes the member
- The member identifies themselves by name and Local – and includes their personal pronouns if they so choose
- The member speaks for or against the resolution or constitutional amendment that is on the floor
Voting at Convention
At Convention we use our own personal devices including a tablet, laptop or smartphone, and an app called Lumi. This is the same way we vote at the Regionals.
- The only official votes at this Convention are for the President and First VP Treasurer, and the ranking of the RVPS.
- The other votes are all electronic “polling” -what used to be a “show of hands”. This is for resolutions and constitutional amendments.
- You must bring your device – if you don’t have one, then notify Convention.
- We will have dedicated charging stations all over the hall
Region order for the mics and floor location is determined by a draw at the Board.
Quick notes on incidental motions
Certain situations need attention during the meeting, but they don’t require a motion, second, debate or voting. It’s permissible to state a point during a meeting where the Chair needs to handle a situation right away. You can declare a Point of Order, Point of Information, Point of Inquiry or Point of Personal Privilege.
- Point of Order: Draw attention to a breach of rules, improper procedure, breaching of established practices, etc.
- Point of Information: Bring up an additional point or additional information (in the form of a non-debatable statement) so that the other members can make fully informed votes.
- Point of Inquiry: Ask for clarification in a report to make better voting decisions.
- Point of Personal Privilege: Address the physical comfort of the setting such as temperature or noise.
Motions are listed in order of precedence. A motion can be introduced if it is higher on the following chart than the pending motion.
| Purpose | You say: | Interrupt? | Second? | Debate? | Amend? | Vote? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fix a time to adjourn | I move to set the next meeting at (time of next meeting) | No | Yes | No | Yes | Majority |
| End meeting | I move to adjourn | No | Yes | No | No | Majority |
| Take break | I move to recess for … | No | Yes | No | Yes | Majority |
| Register complaint | I rise to a question of privilege | Yes | No | No | No | None |
| Make follow agenda | I call for the orders of the day | Yes | No | No | No | None |
| Lay aside temporarily | I move to lay the question on the table | No | Yes | No | No | Majority |
| Close debate | I move the previous question | No | Yes | No | No | 2/3 |
| Limit or extend debate | I move that debate be limited to … | No | Yes | No | Yes | 2/3 |
| Postpone to a certain time | I move to postpone the motion to … | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Majority |
| Refer to committee | I move to refer the motion to … | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Majority |
| Modify wording of motion | I move to amend the motion by … | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Majority |
| Kill main motion | I move that the motion be postponed indefinitely | No | Yes | Yes | No | Majority |
| Bring business before assembly (a main motion) | I move that [or “to”] … | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Majority |
*This chart is from www.robertsrules.org, 2024. Please visit their website for more detailed notes on Roberts Rules of Order.